VTS Market - Listing Share
TL;DR Summary
3,000+
incremental shares in the first 2 months of launch
+61%
more listing and building link shares in the first month after the second release
+65%
increase in the percentage of on-market listings shared
- The ask: Commercial building landlords wanted a simple yet robust way for their brokers to create and manage trackable links to their building and listing pages. They wanted links that could be traced back to a specific marketing channel, broker, and client requirement.
- My role: Led the design of the project from 0 to 1. Conducted exploratory user interviews & testing. Prototyped and iterated on solutions, executed final design flows and developer documentation, and conducted post-development design QA.
- Results: The first release of the listing share workflow resulted in 3,000+ incremental shares in the first 2 months of launch. After receiving post-launch feedback from brokers requesting an easy way to “just grab links,” I designed and implemented a second release, adding a faster, pared-down workflow. This second release resulted in a 61% increase in the number of listing and building link shares in the first month after launch, a 65% increase in percentage of on-market listings shared, and increased broker adoption and satisfaction.
Context
VTS Market is a marketing platform for commercial real estate brokers and landlords. I spent nearly 4 years designing and leading new initiatives and functionalities of the product as it grew to 2,600+ buildings and 8,000+ listings.
Key workflows I designed: listing creation and content management, tools for sharing listings and managing inquiries, and analytics views.
While working on Listing Share, I was on a squad focused on Prospecting, which meant we wanted to help commercial real estate brokers promote their listings and track their leads (also called “requirements”) before they became deals. The vision was to create a “Marketing Command Center” for brokers to market their spaces, manage their leads, and view market analytics data to help them do their jobs more effectively.
By having brokers share the leads they were working on, the landlords that employ the brokers could collect data on the overall demand in the market for spaces, giving them a forward-looking indicator on the types of spaces they should build and promote.
The Design Challenge
To kick start the Marketing Command Center, we needed to give our users a way to share their listings with trackable links. Our landlord customers wanted the ability to create links that were traceable back to a specific marketing channel, broker, and requirement.
However, there was a further twist: though VTS Market’s customers were commercial real estate landlords, my squad’s actual users were the brokers that landlords employ. This difference between the purchasers and the users of a product is a common challenge for designers who work in SaaS. Since we already had a solid understanding of what our landlords wanted, I focused my research on the brokers who would actually be using the product, as their adoption would be critical.
Research & Discovery
I began by conducting exploratory user interviews with brokers to understand their needs. These conversations began by asking about their existing marketing practices and how they tracked leads and deals (in VTS or otherwise) and what the pain points in their workflow were. I then asked more specifically about whether they had visibility into engagement on their marketing activities and whether they had used trackable links of any kind before.
Key learnings:
- Brokers I spoke to had their own homegrown methods of keeping track of their marketing outreach and leads, such as spreadsheets and email folders.
- Brokers didn’t enter prospects and leads into VTS until they were finalizing a deal. This is because they primarily used VTS to share leasing contract details with landlords later in the process, and didn’t want to waste time inputting leads that may not go anywhere.
- These brokers had not used trackable links prior to this. They were intrigued by the idea of trackable links as a way to gauge interest in particular listings, but weren’t convinced they would be useful, as they would reach out to their leads at a regular cadence regardless.
My interpretation of the learnings:
- For this product to succeed, we needed to change existing broker workflows by having them do their marketing and tracking inside of VTS.
- Because the engagement data wouldn’t be an incentive on their own and brokers didn’t want to waste their time filling in forms, we needed to make the process as streamlined as possible to get adoption. The hope was that when brokers saw their engagement data, they would find it useful or interesting, and it would encourage them to continue using VTS Market and improve their results.
- If all else failed, the landlords who employ the brokers have a vested interest in collecting market data, and would therefore encourage them to use the trackable links.
Requirement Definition
After we finished conducting interviews, I partnered with my PM to align on requirements and priorities. We knew that we wanted to give users the ability to create trackable listing links attributable to brokers and mediums, but the specifics needed to be further defined.
Some examples:
- Would any links need to be attributable to both a broker and a medium? No.
- Would the attributed broker always be the same as the user creating the link? Yes, for now.
- Could a link have multiple mediums and brokers attributed to it? No - only one of each.
Posing these types of questions early on helped me narrow the scope of what I needed to design. In fact, some of the answers to the above were different from my expectations, so it was helpful to have clarified them explicitly.
Flow Diagram
After the requirements became clearer, I created a user flow diagram to drive further alignment on how the process might work with my squad and stakeholders. I am always surprised how a flow diagram can provide more clarity and alignment than multiple meetings on the same topic.
In collaboratively reviewing and editing the flow diagram with my squad, I realized that we had two distinct categories of links: personal links and medium-based “generic” links. I also realized that there were two possible entry points into the workflow: from the listings table and from the shares page, where we would store all of the share information.
This not only aligned my PM and engineers on what we were building at a high level, this also informed my wireframes in the next step.
Wireframes
Iteration 1
My first sets of wireframes featured a wizard-type workflow, in which users were guided step-by-step. My reasoning was that brokers may need handholding with the unfamiliar concept of a trackable link.
However, after I reviewed these workflows with my squad, I received the fair critique that this type of workflow, though helpful for new users, could become annoying to frequent users, who would not want to go through a multi-step process each time they needed links. Though it was simple in that it was easy to understand, it wasn’t efficient in the number of steps required.
Since VTS is a B2B SaaS product (like Jira or Salesforce), most of our users are frequent users and we historically prioritized them over new users, who will receive product training. Still, since Market was a new product, I wanted to ensure that new users could understand the process intuitively.
Iteration 2
I balanced the competing needs for efficiency and clarity by offloading the initial share selection step from the modal to a share button with a dropdown. Not only did this reduce the number of steps, it also helped increase user awareness of the different share options.
I prototyped and tested this version with a few brokers, and though they thought the process made sense, several balked at the first modal screen that displayed two required fields: “Contact” and “Requirement name.” They were expecting to see links immediately, and were annoyed by the required fields.
I was perplexed by the feedback, since in my mind, that information was very straightforward — a share is always to someone, and in response to a requirement. Both of those pieces of data would be necessary to make lead tracking useful. Still, I dug deep to think of an even more efficient process to reduce friction.
Iteration 3
In my next iteration, I responded to the user feedback I’d received by consolidating the steps even further. Now, users would see the links immediately alongside the “Share to” and “Requirement info” fields. Both fields were still required, but the “Requirement info” field would auto-populate with the city name and square footage range of the selected listings — a pattern that I call a “smart default.” Users could edit this field, but they no longer needed to fill it out themselves, which left just “Share to” as a required and empty field that should hypothetically be easy to fill out.
Another notable addition was the ability to “Save & Create Deal.” On click, this functionality would directly connect VTS Market to our flagship product, VTS Lease, by automatically filling in listings, contacts, and requirement info to the analogous Deals fields. This would prevent brokers from having to do duplicate work across the VTS platform and, I hoped, would provide further reason for them to fill out those fields.
When I tested this version with users, I received a more positive response than the previous iteration, though some still found entering a contact to be cumbersome. I was very against losing that field, as it was necessary to identify the shares, and after some lively debate, my squad and I collectively decided to include that field in our initial launch.
Design
Going from wireframes to final designs, I experimented with new UI patterns and components where existing design system components fell short.
The dropdown button was a new pattern for VTS that tested well with users, and was necessary both to reduce friction, and to avoid inundating users with too many CTAs as our sharing options grew. I could already envisioning it existing elsewhere across the platform, so I created a reusable component, submitted it as a component to the design system, and partnered with engineering to add it to the Storybook library.
The 2-column modal design was also a new pattern for VTS. Though my wires showed the tracking detail fields above the links, when I mocked up that layout with our actual components and copy, it felt like it took up too much space, and detracted from the links. The 2-column layout allowed me to present a clearer information hierarchy by visually separating inputs from outputs.
With the additional space this layout created, I was able to include helper text to inform and guide users who were unfamiliar with the Personal Link feature. This helped balance the needs of new users and veteran users, as trackable links were easily accessible, but helpful information was available to those who needed it.
I also paid close attention to the micro-interactions around copying links to provide clearer visual feedback. Guerrilla prototype testing indicated that existing affordances weren’t obvious enough: users couldn’t tell whether a link had been successfully copied or whether the action had failed because the button was disabled. To address this, I designed hover states with additional text depending on the button state. I also added a background color change that indicated that the entire row was clickable. When a link was copied successfully, the row flashed light purple and the label changed to “Copied!” Details like these made this workflow feel more dynamic and modern, and reinforced VTS Market’s brand.
Initial Release
The first release (shown above) enabled users to to create unique trackable personal links and view the engagement metrics. This initial workflow resulted in over 3,000 shares in the first 2 months of launch.
Despite our efforts to make this process as efficient and easy as possible, we received post-launch feedback that brokers found this workflow cumbersome and wanted an easier solution for creating and copying links — the same feedback we’d been desperately trying to address since the earliest prototypes.
I had hoped that the workflow as designed would pan out well over time, as brokers got used to the functionality and found benefit in the analytics and deal creation, but we didn’t have the time to see if that was true. My squad was experiencing pressure from client-facing teams to prioritize broker adoption via an easier method of link creation ASAP, even though additional efficiency would undermine the larger goal of data collection and the creation of a robust lead-tracking system.
Follow-up Release
After ideating about how else we could possibly make the process more efficient while still maintaining a semblance of a lead tracking platform, my squad followed up a few sprints later with a one-click personal link workflow for link creation. With a single click, users could now create and copy a personal link for an individual listing directly on the listings table. Links would be immediately saved to the My Shares page and copied to clipboard without further user action, and would no longer require users to input who it was shared with.
This new workflow drastically reduced the number of clicks to create and copy a personal link from 3 to 1, resulting in a 61% increase in the number of listing and link shares in its first month, a 65% increase in percentage of on-market listings shared, and significantly increased broker adoption and satisfaction.
Reflection
Though our follow-up release of one-click personal links was a success from a user experience and engagement metrics perspective, it’s important to note that it came at the cost of creating a system with lower quality data around shares and requirements in the marketplace. The one-click workflow also diluted the data we would have had about which listings tended to be shared together, and made analytics about user engagement less traceable.
This choice led to VTS Market’s eventual pivot away from building a robust lead tracking system, and ironically led to brokers being deprioritized as a user persona. Instead, I would go on to strategize and design new Market initiatives for landlords that did not depend on structured leads data.